Wire cutting of brittle materials split into two competing technologies: free abrasive multi-wire slurry sawing (MWSS) and fixed diamond abrasive wire sawing (DWS). MWSS drags loose abrasive through the kerf in a slurry, which cuts by three-body abrasion; DWS bonds the diamond directly to the wire and cuts by two-body abrasion. DWS delivers roughly 2–3× the cutting efficiency, removes the slurry circulation and disposal problem, and is easier to control — which is why it displaced slurry sawing as the photovoltaic and semiconductor industry scaled up.
The two methods also produce visibly different chip surfaces: slurry cutting leaves a rougher, more damaged surface, while fixed diamond wire leaves a cleaner one.
Cutting is the first operation performed on a hard or brittle workpiece, which makes it the operation that sets the ceiling for everything after it. Internal and external circular saws and band saws impose large cutting-deformation forces, and the material pays for it in subsurface damage, poor form accuracy and a surface that demands heavy grinding and polishing allowances — grinding that costs more than the cutting itself. This analysis traces how wire sawing evolved in response: from free abrasive multi-wire slurry sawing, which used a loose abrasive carried by the wire, to the fixed diamond abrasive wire saw that bonds the diamond to the wire and now dominates precision crystal slicing.
Traditional cutting processes with low processing accuracy result in a significant amount of processing allowance for subsequent grinding and polishing processes, leading to a decrease in overall processing efficiency.
In 1974, Bowman J and H Mech adopted the method of reciprocating cutting using free abrasive to cut brittle materials. I Kao and his team have been dedicated to researching the principles and mechanical analysis of free abrasive machining (FAM) technology. They found that the processing time during semiconductor processing is directly proportional to the square of the processed crystal diameter.
The distribution of abrasive grains and the size of abrasive grain mixtures during free abrasive machining both have an impact on processing quality and material removal rate.
Past research has mainly focused on a single abrasive grain or grain size distribution, and the impact of the distribution of mixed-size abrasive grains on surface characteristics remains unknown. They utilized optical microscopes and image processing techniques to analyze surface features and types, establishing a model for the removal rate of mixed abrasive cutting. ABidiville et al. developed a fracture strength parameterized model based on wire tension, feed rate, and abrasive grain volume size. This model is only applicable to specific process conditions but provides guidance for sawing experiments.
With the development of the photovoltaic industry, the multi-wire slurry sawing (MWSS) using free abrasive has gradually matured. It employs a longer wire with a diameter of 150 to 300 μm, cutting metal wire sizes ranging from 600 to 800 µm, and typically a wire tension of around 20N. Figure 1.18 illustrates the removal mechanism of multi-wire slurry sawing with free abrasive. Two reels are wound with long metal wires, with a tension roller on the right and a release roller on the left. The metal wires are wound in a corresponding manner, forming a parallel and closely spaced multi-wire processing mechanism guided by four wire guides.
During the cutting motion, the slurry injector sprays the slurry to specific locations. The moving wire saw carries the abrasive into the cutting zone, where the abrasives rotate in the cutting gap, generating forces that create cracks and fractures in the material. As the wire and abrasives move, they carry the debris out of the processing area, achieving the removal of brittle materials. The slurry is formulated by mixing polyethylene glycol (PEG) or common oil as the cutting fluid base, then adding abrasives (diamond or silicon carbide particles) and various additives. The cutting fluid possesses suitable viscosity, flow adaptability, and thermal conductivity, providing excellent suspension and dispersion stability for the abrasive micro-particles. The cutting fluid ensures the uniform movement of the abrasive particles by the wire saw.To sustain the cutting process, it is essential to reduce the generated cutting heat and chips effectively.
Figure: mechanism of free abrasive multi-wire cutting (MWSS).

Free Abrasive Machining (FAM) can meet the purpose of narrow kerf cutting, but its surface form accuracy is difficult to control. When the wire saw cuts for a long time, it is challenging to introduce abrasives, reuse slurry circulation, leading to significant environmental pollution. During processing, the abrasives have a cutting effect on both the wire saw and the workpiece, resulting in a lower wire saw lifespan [34]. The Multi-Wire Fixed Diamond Abrasive Wire Saw (DWS) has a cutting efficiency 2-3 times higher than free abrasive cutting [36], and the recovery of cut material when cutting valuable crystals is receiving widespread attention. The fixed diamond wire saw employs a fixed method to attach diamond particles to the wire saw, generating significant cutting force and efficiency without relative motion between the diamond abrasives and the wire saw. The fixed wire saw commonly uses water-based coolant for processing, making the process easy to control with minimal pollution. Figure 1.19 depicts the Nickel-Based Electroplated Diamond Wire Saw.

The above figure shows the mechanism diagram of fixed abrasive multi-wire cutting, indicating that although the wire winding system or machine operation system has similar functions, there are significant differences in the material removal mechanisms between Free Abrasive Multi-Wire Sawing (MWSS) and Multi-Wire Fixed Diamond Abrasive Wire Saw (DWS). In the schematic below illustrating the free abrasive machining mechanism, the rapidly moving wire above carries suspended abrasives into the processing area. With the relative motion between the wire and the cutting material, the suspended abrasives rotate to cut the surfaces of the cutting material and the wire. The cutting material undergoes elastic deformation, plastic deformation, microcracks, and fracture, ultimately achieving material removal. Tribology refers to this process as three-body abrasion.
Figure: chip and surface morphology after free abrasive cutting.

Figure: chip and surface morphology after fixed abrasive cutting.

The two processes look similar on the machine — both run wire through a guide system and both produce wafers — but the material-removal mechanism is fundamentally different, and almost every practical difference follows from that.
| Parameter | MWSS — free abrasive slurry | DWS — fixed diamond abrasive wire |
|---|---|---|
| Abrasive delivery | Suspended in slurry, injected into the cutting zone | Bonded to the wire surface (electroplated nickel) |
| Removal mechanism | Three-body abrasion (abrasive rolls between wire and workpiece) | Two-body abrasion (diamond cuts directly, no relative motion) |
| Wire diameter | 150 – 300 μm metal wire | Matched to the wafer specification |
| Wire tension | Around 20 N | Higher, and easier to hold constant |
| Cutting efficiency | Baseline | Approximately 2–3× higher |
| Cutting fluid | PEG or oil base with abrasive and additives | Water-based coolant |
| Slurry handling | Circulation, reuse and disposal required; significant environmental load | No slurry to circulate or dispose of; minimal pollution |
| Wire life | Abrasive wears the wire as well as the workpiece, shortening life | Diamond is fixed; wear concentrates on the grit |
| Process control | Surface form accuracy difficult to hold; long cuts introduce abrasive harder to replenish | Kerr and surface quality easier to control and repeat |
| Best fit | Legacy photovoltaic lines; very large-diameter ingots | Precision crystal slicing where kerf loss and surface quality both matter |
As mentioned above, in the past few years, the fixed diamond wire saw has rapidly developed, and many researchers are studying this new technology in terms of crystal slicing quality. From Figure chips after free abrasive cutting and chips after fixed diamond abrasive cutting, the surface morphology SEM images show the different surface morphologies produced by the two processing methods. Factors affecting the cutting quality of crystal materials include the total thickness variation (TTV) of the chips, surface quality (surface roughness, surface form accuracy), mechanical strength of the chips, and cutting losses. The material removal mechanisms of the two cutting methods, MWSS (three-body abrasion) and DWS (two-body abrasion), result in chips of different surface qualities.
Q1: What is the difference between free abrasive and fixed abrasive wire cutting?
In free abrasive cutting the diamond or SiC grit travels loose in a slurry and is dragged into the kerf by the wire — a three-body abrasion process. In fixed abrasive cutting the diamond is bonded directly to the wire, so the cutting edges are fixed in place — two-body abrasion. The fixed process cuts faster and leaves a cleaner surface because the abrasive cannot roll away from the cut.
Q2: Why did fixed diamond wire sawing replace slurry sawing?
Three reasons. It cuts about two to three times faster; it removes the slurry circulation, reuse and disposal burden, along with most of the associated environmental load; and it is far easier to control, so kerf width and surface form accuracy become repeatable. Once the photovoltaic industry needed to slice ingots at scale, those advantages decided the outcome.
Q3: Which process gives a better surface finish?
Fixed diamond abrasive wire sawing. Because the diamond is bonded and cannot roll freely, the material removal is more controlled and chips come away with a cleaner surface morphology. Surface quality is also measurable: total thickness variation (TTV), roughness, form accuracy and mechanical strength of the sliced wafer all fall out of the removal mechanism.
Q4: What cutting fluid does each process need?
Slurry sawing uses a formulated fluid — typically polyethylene glycol or a light oil as the base, with abrasive particles and additives to give the right viscosity, flow behaviour and thermal conductivity, plus suspension stability so the abrasive stays evenly dispersed. Fixed diamond wire sawing normally runs on water-based coolant, which is both simpler and far less polluting.
Ensoll Tools offers free test cutting: if you are weighing slurry sawing against fixed diamond wire, send us a representative workpiece and we will return the cut part with surface data so the comparison is made on your material rather than on a specification sheet. Tell us the material, the kerf allowed and the surface quality you need, and our engineers will recommend the wire specification. Call +86 191 3977 6428 or send your sample details through the contact page.
Supplied by ENSOLLTECH PTE. LTD.
ENSOLLTECH PTE. LTD. is a Singapore company (UEN 202551184N), registered at 266A South Bridge Road, #02-01, Singapore 058815. We supply endless diamond wire loops and diamond wire saw machines; the products are manufactured at our group’s own ISO 9001-certified plant in Zhengzhou, China — not sourced from third-party traders.
Company profile: About ENSOLLTECH · Technical enquiry: Contact our Singapore office
If you have any question, please contact us